House Roll Call 283, 104th Congress · April 5, 1995
H.R.1215 BY ARCHER (R-TX) -- TAX FAIRNESS AND DEFICIT REDUCTION ACT OF 1995 DISCRETIONARY SPENDING REDUCTION AND CONTROL ACT OF 1995 USEC PRIVATIZATION ACT CONGRESSINAL AND FEDERAL EMPLOYEE RETIREMENT EQUALIZATION ACT MEDICARE PRESIDENTIAL BUDGET SAVINGS EXTENSION ACT OF 1995 CONTRACT WITH AMERICA TAX RELIEF ACT OF 1995 (HOUSE REJECTED THE GEPHARDT AMENDMENT IN THE NATURE OF A SUBSTITUTE THAT SOUGHT TO PROVIDE TAX DEDUCTIONS FOR LOW-INCOME FAMILIES TO SUPPORT COSTS OF HIGHER EDUCTION; CREATE A NEW TYPE OF SAVINGS BONDS CALLED "GUARANTEED EDUCATION PLAN BONDS"; PROVIDE FOR PENALTY-FREE WITHDRAWAL OF CURRENT IRAS TO PAY FOR HIGHER EDUCATION COSTS, RAISE THE ELIGIBILITY LIMIT TO $85,000 FOR COUPLES FILING A JOINT RETURN AND TO $60,000 FOR SINGLE TAXPAYERS AND PHASE IN AN ADDITIONAL $2,000 DEDUCTION CONTRIBUTION FOR SPOUSES; ESTABLISH A NEW NONDEDUCTIBLE TAX-FREE IRA SUBJECT TO CURRENT LAW INCOME ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS; DELAY THE EFFECTIVE DATES OF THESE TAX PROVISIONS UNTIL THE OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET CERTIFIED THE FEDERAL BUDGET WILL BE BALANCED BY FISCAL YEAR 2002 AND SUSPENDS THEM IF THE FEDERAL BUDGET DEFICIT DOES NOT MEET SPECIFIC REDUCTION TARGETS; EXTEND THE PAYGO PROVISION THROUGH FISCAL YEAR 2000 AND REDUCE MANDATORY CAPS ON DISCRETIONARY SPENDING FOR FISCAL YEARS 1996-1998 AND EXTEND THEM THROUGH FISCAL YEAR 2000; PERMIT THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE TO TAX ESTATES OF EXPATRIATES WHO RENOUNCE THEIR CITIZENSHIP; AND ESTABLISH NEW REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR RESIDENTS AND CITIZENS WHO MOVE ASSETS INTO OR RECEIVE INCOME FROM FOREIGN TRUSTS.)
Question before the chamber: On agreeing to the Substitute Amendment
Solid = yea, faded = nay.
The measure
Tax Fairness and Deficit Reduction Act of 1995
Policy area: Taxation — assigned by Library of Congress subject specialists, not by this site.
How this vote is scored
Which tracked issues this roll call counts toward, and which way a yea vote moves a member on each. Direction is decided per issue, because one bill can push two issues opposite ways.
- Health CareDirection unreadable — not scored
excluded:model-unclear (0.95) The substitute amendment concerns tax, education, and spending caps, not health care coverage.
Tagged by: keyword:medicare
Axis: Expand coverage ← → Restrict coverage
- TaxesA yea counts toward “Raise revenue”
model(0.90): The substitute delays tax cuts and taxes expatriate estates, raising revenue relative to the underlying bill.
Tagged by: policy-area:Taxation
Axis: Raise revenue ← → Cut taxes
- Spending & BudgetA yea counts toward “Fiscal restraint”
model(0.90): Conditioning tax cuts on deficit targets and lowering discretionary spending caps enforces fiscal restraint.
Tagged by: keyword:deficit reduction
Axis: Fiscal expansion ← → Fiscal restraint
Who voted which way
Every member recorded on this roll call, with the party they sat with at the time.
Yea (119)
- Neil Abercrombie
- Gary L. Ackerman
- Robert E. Andrews
- John Baldacci
- James A. Barcia
- Tom Bevill
- David E. Bonior
- Robert A. Borski
- Frederick C. Boucher
- John Glen Browder
- Corrine Brown
- Sherrod Brown
- William Lacy Clay Sr.
- Eva Clayton
- Robert Clement
- James E. Clyburn
- Ronald D’Emory Coleman
- Barbara-Rose Collins
- Cardiss Collins
- John Conyers, Jr.
- Robert E. Cramer Jr.
- Pat Danner
- Eligio II de la Garza
- Rosa L. DeLauro
- John D. Dingell
- Julian C. Dixon
- Richard J. Durbin
- Thomas Edwards
- Eliot L. Engel
- Anna G. Eshoo
- Lane A. Evans
- Sam Farr
- Chaka Fattah
- Victor Herbert Fazio Jr.
- Bob Filner
- Floyd Harold Flake
- Thomas Michael Foglietta
- Harold Eugene Ford
- Barney Frank
- Jonas Frost III
- Sam Gejdenson
- Richard Andrew Gephardt
- Henry Barbosa González
- Barton Jennings Gordon
- Luis V. Gutiérrez
- Alcee L. Hastings
- Willie Gathrel Hefner
- Maurice D. Hinchey
- Tim Holden
- Sheila Jackson Lee
- William J. Jefferson
- Eddie Bernice Johnson
- Tim Johnson
- Harry A. Johnston II
- Patrick Joseph Kennedy
- Barbara Bailey Kennelly
- Tom Lantos
- Sander M. Levin
- John Lewis
- Zoe Lofgren
- Nita M. Lowey
- Carolyn B. Maloney
- Thomas J. Manton
- Edward J. Markey
- Matthew G. Martínez
- Frank Mascara
- Robert T. Matsui
- Paul F. McHale Jr.
- Carrie Meek
- Robert Menendez
- George Miller
- Norman Yoshio Mineta
- Patsy Takemoto Mink
- John Joseph Moakley
- James P. Moran
- Jerrold Nadler
- Richard E. Neal
- James L. Oberstar
- David Ross Obey
- John W. Olver
- Major R. Owens
- Frank Pallone, Jr.
- Donald M. Payne
- Collin C. Peterson
- Earl Ralph Pomeroy
- Nick J. Rahall II
- Jack Reed
- William Blaine Richardson
- Charles Grandison Rose III
- Bobby L. Rush
- Martin Olav Sabo
- Bernard Sanders
- Thomas C. Sawyer
- Patricia Scott Schroeder
- Charles E. Schumer
- José E. Serrano
- Louise McIntosh Slaughter
- John McKee Spratt Jr.
- Louis Stokes
- Gerry Eastman Studds
- Bart T. Stupak
- John S. Tanner
- Bennie G. Thompson
- Raymond Hoyt Thornton Jr.
- Esteban Edward Torres
- Robert Torricelli
- Edolphus Towns
- James A. Traficant Jr.
- Walter R. Tucker III
- Nydia M. Velázquez
- Bruce F. Vento
- Harold Lee Volkmer
- Michael Delavan Ward
- Henry A. Waxman
- Robert E. Wise Jr.
- Lynn C. Woolsey
- Ron Wyden
- Albert Russell Wynn
- Sidney Richard Yates
Nay (313)
- Wayne A. Allard
- Bill Archer
- Richard K. Armey
- Spencer Bachus
- Henry Scott Baesler
- Richard Hugh Baker
- William P. Baker
- Cass Ballenger
- Bob Barr
- Bill Barrett
- Thomas M. Barrett
- Roscoe G. Bartlett
- Joe Barton
- Charles F. Bass
- Herbert H. Bateman
- Xavier Becerra
- Anthony Charles Beilenson
- Ken Bentsen
- Douglas K. Bereuter
- Howard L. Berman
- Brian P. Bilbray
- Michael Bilirakis
- Sanford D. Bishop, Jr.
- Tom Bliley
- Peter I. Blute
- Sherwood L. Boehlert
- John A. Boehner
- Henry Bonilla
- Sonny Bono
- William K. Brewster
- George E. Brown Jr.
- Samuel D. Brownback
- Ed Bryant
- John Wiley Bryant
- Jim Bunn
- Jim Bunning
- Richard Burr
- Dan Burton
- Stephen E. Buyer
- H. L. Callahan
- Ken Calvert
- Dave Camp
- Charles T. Canady
- Benjamin L. Cardin
- Michael N. Castle
- Steve Chabot
- Saxby Chambliss
- Jim Chapman
- Helen Chenoweth-Hage
- Jon Lynn Christensen
- Dick Chrysler
- William Floyd Clinger Jr.
- Howard Coble
- Tom Coburn
- Michael Allen Collins
- Larry Combest
- Gary Condit
- Wes Cooley
- Jerry F. Costello
- C. Christopher Cox
- William J. Coyne
- Philip M. Crane
- Mike Crapo
- Frank Cremeans
- Barbara L. Cubin
- Randall H. Cunningham
- Thomas M. Davis III
- Nathan Deal
- Peter A. DeFazio
- Thomas Dale DeLay
- Ronald Vernie Dellums
- Peter Deutsch
- Lincoln Diaz-Balart
- Jay Dickey
- Norman D. Dicks
- Lloyd Doggett
- Calvin M. Dooley
- John T. Doolittle
- Robert Kenneth Dornan
- Michael F. Doyle
- David Dreier
- John J. Duncan, Jr.
- Jennifer B. Dunn
- Vernon J. Ehlers
- Robert L. Ehrlich Jr.
- Norvell William Emerson
- Philip English
- John Eric Ensign
- Terry Everett
- Thomas W. Ewing
- Harris W. Fawell
- Cleo Fields
- Jack Milton Fields Jr.
- Michael P. Flanagan
- Mark Adam Foley
- Michael P. Forbes
- Tillie K. Fowler
- Jon D. Fox
- Bob Franks
- Gary A. Franks
- Rodney P. Frelinghuysen
- Dan Frisa
- David Funderburk
- Elizabeth Furse
- Elton Gallegly
- Greg Ganske
- George W. Gekas
- Preston M. Geren
- Sam Melville Gibbons
- Wayne T. Gilchrest
- Paul E. Gillmor
- Benjamin Gilman
- Bob Goodlatte
- William F. Goodling
- Porter J. Goss
- Lindsey Graham
- Gene Green
- Enid Greene Waldholtz
- James C. Greenwood
- Steven Craig Gunderson
- Gilbert W. Gutknecht
- Ralph M. Hall
- Tony P. Hall
- Lee Herbert Hamilton
- Melton D. Hancock
- James V. Hansen
- Jane Harman
- J. Dennis Hastert
- Doc Hastings
- James Allison Hayes
- John D. Hayworth Jr.
- Joel Hefley
- Fred Heineman
- Wally Herger
- Van Hilleary
- Earl F. Hilliard
- David Lee Hobson
- Peter Hoekstra
- Martin R. Hoke
- Stephen Horn
- John Nathan Hostettler
- Amory Houghton Jr.
- Steny H. Hoyer
- Duncan L. Hunter
- Tim Hutchinson
- Henry John Hyde
- Bob Inglis
- Ernest J. Istook Jr.
- Andrew Jacobs Jr.
- Nancy Lee Johnson
- Sam Johnson
- Walter B. Jones
- Paul E. Kanjorski
- Marcy Kaptur
- John R. Kasich
- Sue W. Kelly
- Joseph Patrick Kennedy II
- Dale E. Kildee
- Jay Kim
- Peter T. King
- Jack Kingston
- Gerald D. Kleczka
- Ron Klink
- Scott L. Klug
- Joseph K. Knollenberg
- James T. Kolbe
- John J. LaFalce
- Ray H. LaHood
- Steve Largent
- Tom Latham
- Steven C. LaTourette
- Gregory H. Laughlin
- Rick A. Lazio
- James A. Leach
- Jerry Lewis
- Ron Lewis
- James Ross Lightfoot
- Blanche Lambert Lincoln
- John Linder
- William O. Lipinski
- Robert Linligthgow Livingston Jr.
- Frank A. LoBiondo
- James Longley
- Frank D. Lucas
- William Luther
- Donald A. Manzullo
- William J. Martini
- Karen McCarthy
- Bill McCollum
- James O. McCrery III
- Joseph Michael McDade
- Jim McDermott
- John M. McHugh
- Scott McInnis
- David M. McIntosh
- Howard P. "Buck" McKeon
- Cynthia McKinney
- Michael R. McNulty
- Martin T. Meehan
- Jack Metcalf
- Jan Meyers
- Kweisi Mfume
- John L. Mica
- Dan Miller
- David Minge
- Susan Molinari
- Alan B. Mollohan
- Gillespie V. Montgomery
- Carlos John Moorhead
- Constance Morella
- John P. Murtha
- John Thomas Myers
- Sue Wilkins Myrick
- George R. Nethercutt Jr.
- Mark W. Neumann
- Robert William Ney
- Charles W. Norwood Jr.
- James Allen Nussle
- Solomon P. Ortiz
- William Orton
- Michael G. Oxley
- Ron Packard
- Michael Parker
- Ed Pastor
- L. William Paxon
- Lewis Franklin Payne Jr.
- Douglas Brian Peterson
- Thomas E. Petri
- Owen B. Pickett
- Richard W. Pombo
- John Edward Porter
- Rob Portman
- Glenn Poshard
- Deborah D. Pryce
- James Henry Quillen
- Jack Quinn
- George P. Radanovich
- James M. Ramstad
- Charles B. Rangel
- Ralph Regula
- Frank D. Riggs
- Lynn Rivers
- Pat Roberts
- Timothy Roemer
- Harold Rogers
- Dana Rohrabacher
- Ileana Ros-Lehtinen
- Toby A. Roth
- Marge Roukema
- Lucille Roybal-Allard
- Edward R. Royce
- Matt Salmon
- Mark Sanford
- H. James Saxton
- Joe Scarborough
- Daniel Schaefer
- Steven Harvey Schiff
- Robert C. "Bobby" Scott
- Andrea Seastrand
- F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr.
- John B. Shadegg
- E. Clay Shaw Jr.
- Christopher H. Shays
- Elmer Greinert Shuster
- Norman Sisisky
- David Evans Skaggs
- Joseph Skeen
- Ike Skelton
- Christopher H. Smith
- Lamar Smith
- Linda Smith
- Nick Smith
- Gerald Brooks Hunt Solomon
- Mark Edward Souder
- Floyd Spence
- Fortney Pete Stark
- Cliff Stearns
- Charles W. Stenholm
- Steve Stockman
- Robert Stump
- James M. Talent
- Randy J. Tate
- William J. Tauzin
- Charles H. Taylor
- Gene Taylor
- Frank Mariano Tejeda
- William M. Thomas
- Mac Thornberry
- Karen Thurman
- Todd Tiahrt
- Peter Gerard Torkildsen
- Fred Upton
- Peter J. Visclosky
- Barbara Farrell Vucanovich
- Robert Smith Walker
- James T. Walsh
- Zach Wamp
- Maxine Waters
- Melvin L. Watt
- J.C. Watts
- David J. Weldon Jr.
- W. Curtis Weldon
- Gerald C. Weller
- Richard Alan White
- Ed Whitfield
- Roger F. Wicker
- John Patrick Williams
- Charles Wilson
- Frank R. Wolf
- C. W. Bill Young
- Don Young
- William H. Zeliff Jr.
- Richard Zimmer
Not voting or present (2)
- Nancy PelosiDid not vote
- Mel ReynoldsDid not vote
Vote records come from Voteview (voteview.com); bill titles and policy areas from the congress.gov API. See methodology for how the record was built.